LETTERS TO THE EDITOR Familial Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease with D178N-129M mutation of PRNP presenting as cerebellar ataxia without insomnia

Fatal familial insomnia (FFI) is a prion disease clinically characterised by progressive insomnia and dysautonomia, and associated with an aspartic acid to asparagine mutation at the codon 178 (D178N) of the prion protein gene (PRNP). This mutation is also associated with familial Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD). These phenotypes have been held to depend on the polymorphism at the codon 129. FFI and CJD phenotypes are associated with methionine (129M) and valine (129V) polymorphisms, respectively. However, the diverse phenotypes can be associated with D178N-129M genotype. 4 We here report on a Japanese family with D178N-129M genotype presenting cerebellar ataxia without overt insomnia. The pedigree of this family is depicted in the the figure. Patient 1 (II-5), a 50 year old man, a proband, noted an unsteady gait in October 1997 and diYculty in speech in December 1997. These symptoms worsened rapidly. He had no episodes of insomnia, hallucination, or involuntary movement. On admission, he was normal in general condition, well oriented, and cooperative, but slightly restless. The Wechsler adult intelligence scale revised (WAIS-R) score was normal (verbal IQ 108 and performance IQ 95). He showed saccadic ocular movements and nystagmoid movements on lateral gaze. His speech was explosive and scanning. Myoclonus was not evident. The muscle tone and strength were normal. He presented moderate bilateral limb ataxia. He could barely stand and walk on a wide base, and tandem gait was impossible. The deep tendon reflexes were normal in his arms and mildly brisk in his legs without Babinski’s sign. Sensory examination was normal. Autonomic signs were absent. Routine laboratory and CSF examinations were normal. An EEG showed a background of 9 Hz á activities spreading to the anterior regions without periodic synchronous discharges (PSDs). The sleep EEG overnight for 3 days showed a normal sleep pattern in which spindles, K complexes, slow activities, and REM sleep were seen. Brain MRI showed mild cerebellar atrophy. Single photon emission CT (SPECT) using [99m]Tc-HMPAO showed hypoperfusion in the bilateral frontal lobe and left parietal region, and left striatum. One year after the onset, he still did not develop either dementia or myoclonus. In July 1995, patient 2 (II-3), an elder brother of patient 1 developed an ataxic gait and forgetfulness at the age of 55 years followed by dysarthria within a month. He had limb ataxia in his arms. The deep tendon reflexes were normal in his arms and mildly brisk in his legs without Babinski’s sign. In November 1995, EEG showed diVuse intermittent slow activities without PSDs. In January 1996, he developed akinetic mutism and myoclonic jerks. Brain CT demonstrated moderate cerebellar atrophy. He presented a decorticate posture and died of respiratory failure 7 months after the onset. Patient 3 (I-1), the father of patient 1, developed an ataxic gait and dementia at the age of 55. He died of an unknown cause after a clinical course of 12 months. The 848 bp open reading frame of PRNP was amplified by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) using peripheral leucocyte DNA. The mutation at the codon 178 and the polymorphism at the codon 129 were screened by restriction analyses with Tth 111I and Nsp I as described elsewhere. The D178N mutation abolishes a Tth 111I site. The restriction analysis of the PCR product shows a non-digested 848 bp fragment in the mutant allele and 575 and 273 bp ones in the normal allele. As shown in the figure, theTth 111I digestion generated three fragments of 848, 575, and 273 bp in patient 1 and his child (III-1), indicative of both having a heterozygous D178N mutation. The 129V polymorphism abolishes one of the two Nsp 1 sites in the PCR product. The restriction analysis shows 502 and 346 bp fragments in the 129V allele, and 427, 346, and 75 bp ones in the 129M allele. Four fragments were detected in patient 1 and three smaller fragments in his child, which indicated that patient 1 was heterozygous for 129V and 129M and that his child was homozygous for 129M. The sequencing of PCR products demonstrated that D178N mutation and 129M polymorphism were on the same allele in patient 1. Rapidly progressive cerebellar ataxia was present in two generation of this family. Patient 2 presented progressive dementia and myoclonus, which suggested a diagnosis of familial CJD. The FFI mutation on the 129M allele was found in the examined members of this family. All the patients, however, lacked insomnia clinically, and EEG showed a normal sleep pattern in patient 1. Although pathological findings were not assessed, SPECT in patient 1 did not disclose abnormalities in the thalamus, usually involved in FFI. The phenotype in this family was clearly diVerent from that of FFI. Thus, the supposed dependence of the phenotypes with the FFI mutation on the polymorphism at the codon 129 was not true of the present family. It was already reported in white people that the clinical presentations associated with the FFI genotype are diverse, including cerebellar ataxia, dementia, and autonomic abnormalities with or without insomnia. 4 Our findings support the notion that the phenotypic variability in the FFI genotype exists throughout various ethnic backgrounds, and emphasises the heterogeneity of inherited prion disease.